Sugarlands vs Old Forge Distillery: Prices, Tastings & Reviews

Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge both sit at the center of Tennessee’s moonshine boom, and two names come up constantly when visitors plan a tasting stop: Sugarlands Distilling Company and Old Forge Distillery. Both pour flavored moonshine by the sample, both welcome walk-ins, and both make for an easy 20-30 minute stop on a busy sightseeing day.

But the experiences aren’t the same. One charges a flat fee for a big flavor lineup in a lively downtown tasting room; the other leans on free samples inside a historic mill complex. Here’s how the two actually compare — prices, flavor counts, hours, and what reviewers say — so you can decide which one earns a spot on your itinerary, or whether it’s worth doing both.

Quick Answer

Want the biggest flavor lineup and a lively, guided $5 tasting? Go to Sugarlands Distilling Company in downtown Gatlinburg. Want to sample for free with no pressure to buy, inside a scenic historic mill setting? Old Forge Distillery at The Old Mill in Pigeon Forge is the better stop. Both are worth doing if you have time for a mini distillery crawl between the two towns.

Sugarlands Distilling Company: Tasting, Prices & What to Expect

Sugarlands Distilling Company sits at 805 Parkway in downtown Gatlinburg, right in the thick of the strip’s foot traffic. The tasting costs $5 per person and gets you 12 samples poured at an octagon-shaped bar, with a tastemaker walking you through each pour and explaining the moonshine and sippin’ cream lineup. That lineup rotates daily, so no two visits are identical, and the $5 you pay comes back as a $5 credit toward merchandise — a detail that softens the cost if you’re already planning to buy a bottle.

Sugarlands is open daily, with hours posted on its official site that run from 10 a.m. into the evening (hours shift seasonally around the holidays and in early winter, so check the current schedule before you go), and walk-ins are welcome for tastings with no reservation required. Reservations only come into play for the guided distillery tour, which runs on weekends. Anyone tasting must be 21 or older with valid photo ID, though minors are welcome to tag along and browse the shop.

Old Forge Distillery Prices: What the Tasting Actually Costs

Old Forge Distillery, at 170 Old Mill Ave inside The Old Mill complex in Pigeon Forge, keeps its core tasting free: up to 10 samples pulled from a catalog of roughly 27 moonshine flavors, plus vodka and rum. The only prices you’ll run into are for two higher-proof, barrel-aged pours — the Harvest Gin and the Blended Bourbon Whiskey — which carry a small $3 tasting fee on top of the free flight. That makes Old Forge the cheaper of the two core experiences, since Sugarlands charges $5 up front for every taster.

Old Forge doesn’t run formal guided tours, but the still and production area are visible from the main tasting room, so you still get a behind-the-scenes feel without booking anything or paying extra. Hours generally run from mid-morning into the evening daily, with the official site noting it’s open Sundays too; check the link below for the current schedule before you go, since hours shift seasonally. Like Sugarlands, everyone tasting must be 21-plus with ID.

Is Sugarlands Distilling Company in Pigeon Forge?

No — Sugarlands’ tasting room and distillery are in downtown Gatlinburg at 805 Parkway, not Pigeon Forge. It’s an easy mix-up because so many Smoky Mountains itineraries bounce between the two towns, and other moonshine brands (notably Ole Smoky) do operate a separate location on The Island in Pigeon Forge. If you’re staying in Pigeon Forge and want a moonshine tasting without the drive to Gatlinburg, Old Forge Distillery at The Old Mill is your in-town option; Sugarlands is roughly a 10-15 minute drive away and worth the trip if you want the bigger flavor lineup and the downtown Gatlinburg energy.

Atmosphere and Location Make the Real Difference

Sugarlands sits right on the Gatlinburg Parkway, in the thick of downtown foot traffic, arcades, and candy shops. The tasting room has a bigger, louder, more produced feel — think octagon bar, staff patter, and periodic in-person visits from cast members of the Moonshiners TV show, who come to distill on a published monthly schedule (typically the first Wednesday and a Friday each month). No tickets are needed for those appearances; visitors just line up for a photo and autograph, and dates are always subject to change, so check Sugarlands’ events page before counting on one.

Old Forge is part of The Old Mill historic complex in Pigeon Forge, alongside a working gristmill, restaurants, and a candy kitchen. The setting is quieter and more scenic, with the mill and creek right outside. Because the core tastings are free and there’s no formal tour to book, it’s an easier in-and-out stop if you’re short on time or already exploring The Old Mill’s shops and restaurants. Neither location has dedicated on-site parking that’s guaranteed easy: Sugarlands relies on a nearby garage and street parking, while Old Forge shares The Old Mill’s lot, which fills up on weekends.

Planning Your Visit: Hours, Tours & Official Info

Both distilleries price their tastings in simple, flat tiers rather than timed-ticket systems — you pay (or don’t) at the counter and taste on the spot, so there’s no need to book a time slot for a basic tasting at either one. Sugarlands is the exception for anything beyond tasting: its weekend distillery tour requires advance booking, while Old Forge has no formal tour to reserve at all. Hours at both run daily but shift with the season, especially around major holidays, so always check the current posted hours before you plan your stop.

For the exact current hours, tasting lineup, and any seasonal pricing changes, use each distillery’s own site as the canonical source: Sugarlands Distilling Company’s official site and Old Forge Distillery’s official site.

What Visitors Say in Reviews

Reviews of Sugarlands tend to praise the energy of the tasting room — the tastemakers’ banter, the sheer number of flavors, and the novelty of the merch credit — while some visitors note it feels touristy and can get crowded with the Parkway foot traffic, especially in the evening. Reviews of Old Forge skew toward praise for the no-pressure, free-tasting format and the quieter Old Mill setting, with the trade-off being a smaller footprint since there’s no guided tour and the still is only viewable from the tasting room, not walked through.

A common thread across reviews of both: the flavor lineup changes often, so a specific moonshine or cream you read about in someone else’s review may not be pouring the day you visit. Treat any single review’s flavor list as a snapshot, not a guarantee.

Tips and Common Mistakes

Don’t assume both tastings are free — Sugarlands charges $5 up front (credited back to merch), while Old Forge’s core flight is free but its two premium spirits add a $3 charge. Check which flavors are pouring that day; both distilleries rotate their lineups, so a flavor you loved in someone else’s review might not be on the bar when you visit.

If you’re hoping to meet a Moonshiners cast member at Sugarlands, don’t plan around a random weekend visit — appearances follow a specific monthly schedule posted on Sugarlands’ events page, so confirm the date before you go. If you want the Sugarlands guided tour rather than just the tasting, book ahead online since tours only run on weekends. Don’t confuse Sugarlands’ Gatlinburg address with a Pigeon Forge location — it’s not in Pigeon Forge, so budget drive time if you’re staying there. Bring ID even if you look well over 21, since both places enforce it strictly. Finally, if you’re doing both distilleries in one day, go earlier rather than later; tasting rooms get crowded once evening foot traffic picks up on the Parkway and at The Old Mill.

Photos

Sugarlands vs Old Forge Distillery FAQs

Which is cheaper, Sugarlands or Old Forge?

Old Forge is cheaper for the core experience since its moonshine flight (up to 10 samples) is free; only its Harvest Gin and Blended Bourbon Whiskey carry a $3 fee. Sugarlands charges $5 per person for its 12-flavor tasting, though that $5 comes back as store credit.

What are Old Forge Distillery’s tasting prices?

Old Forge’s core moonshine, vodka, and rum tastings are free — up to 10 samples from around 27 flavors. The only charge is a small $3 fee for two premium pours, the Harvest Gin and the Blended Bourbon Whiskey. There’s no fee just to walk in and taste the standard lineup.

Is Sugarlands Distilling Company located in Pigeon Forge?

No. Sugarlands’ distillery and tasting room are in downtown Gatlinburg at 805 Parkway, not Pigeon Forge. If you want a moonshine tasting based in Pigeon Forge itself, Old Forge Distillery at The Old Mill is the local option; Sugarlands is about a 10-15 minute drive from central Pigeon Forge.

What is the Sugarlands moonshine tasting actually like?

You pay $5 at an octagon-shaped bar and a tastemaker pours and walks you through 12 rotating moonshine and sippin’ cream flavors. It’s a guided, narrated experience rather than a self-serve flight, and the $5 comes back as a merchandise credit. The whole tasting takes about 20-30 minutes.

Do I need a reservation for either tasting?

No, walk-ins are welcome for tastings at both. Sugarlands only requires booking ahead for its guided distillery tour, which runs on weekends; Old Forge has no formal tour to book at all.

Which has more flavors to try?

Old Forge has the larger overall flavor catalog at around 27 moonshine varieties, though you only sample up to 10 per visit. Sugarlands pours 12 rotating flavors per tasting session.

Can I meet the cast of Moonshiners at Sugarlands?

Sometimes. Cast members like Mark and Digger make periodic appearances at the Gatlinburg distillery on a published monthly schedule (generally the first Wednesday and a Friday each month), with no ticket needed — just a line for photos and autographs. Dates change, so check Sugarlands’ events page before planning a visit around one.

Plan Your Smokies Trip

Build your own Smoky Mountains itinerary — save the cabins, attractions, and restaurants you want to hit. Try the free ExploreTheSmokies trip builder.