Ask ten people for the best restaurant in Pigeon Forge and at least half will name Bennett’s Pit Bar-B-Que or Local Goat. They’re both parkway staples, both draw lines out the door on a Friday night, and both show up near the top of every “where to eat in Pigeon Forge” list — but they’re not really competing for the same meal.
This guide breaks down what each restaurant actually serves, what it costs, how long you’ll wait, and which one fits your trip better, so you’re not stuck flipping a coin in the parking lot.
Quick Answer
Pick Bennett’s BBQ for hickory-smoked ribs, pulled pork, and classic smokehouse platters in a laid-back, family-style setting. Pick Local Goat for a bigger, more creative menu — gourmet burgers, steaks, craft cocktails, and shareable apps — in a livelier bar-and-dinner atmosphere. If you want classic smokehouse BBQ, go Bennett’s; if you want more menu variety and a full bar, go Local Goat.
What Each Restaurant Actually Serves
Bennett’s Pit Bar-B-Que has been family owned and operated in Pigeon Forge for decades, with locations on the Parkway (2910 Parkway, between traffic lights #4 and #5) and in Gatlinburg. The menu centers on hickory-smoked meats — pulled pork, ribs, chicken, and brisket — smoked for hours and basted in Bennett’s own sauce, which is served warm on the side so you control how much you use. Beyond the smoked platters, the menu also includes starters like wings and fried pickles, soups and salads, sandwiches, chargrilled burgers, a kids menu, and family-style feasts to go. The Pigeon Forge location opens at 11 a.m., so it’s built around lunch and dinner rather than breakfast.
Local Goat, on Parkway near Rowdy Bear’s Smoky Mountain Snowpark, bills itself as a New American restaurant and casts a much wider net. Expect jumbo wings, deep-fried deviled eggs, salads built around locally sourced greens, fall-off-the-bone ribs, steaks, and a well-known lineup of gourmet burgers — including the TN Whiskey Glazed Burger and The Elvis (peanut butter, bacon, and fried bananas). The kitchen makes its own bread daily, and there’s a full bar with craft beer, cocktails, and specialty drinks, which Bennett’s doesn’t offer. Desserts like the Warm Chocolate Lava Cake round out a menu built for a full sit-down dinner rather than a quick smokehouse plate.
Price, Wait Times, and Atmosphere
Bennett’s leans toward the more affordable, casual end — think family-restaurant pricing and a dining room set up for turning tables quickly during lunch and dinner rushes. It’s a solid choice if you’re traveling with kids or want a filling meal without a long ordering process, and it opens at 11 a.m. daily.
Local Goat runs a bit pricier and skews toward a livelier, bar-forward atmosphere with a dining room decorated by local artists and craftsmen. It’s popular enough that the parking lot is routinely full, and long waits without a reservation are common, especially at dinner. Local Goat takes online reservations for parties of ten or fewer (larger groups need to call), while Bennett’s is generally walk-in and doesn’t require booking ahead. If you’re set on Local Goat for dinner, reserve a table in advance — lunch tends to have little to no wait, but evenings fill up fast.
Tips / Common Mistakes
Don’t show up to Local Goat on a Friday or Saturday night without a reservation and expect a quick seat — book ahead or plan for a wait. Don’t go to Bennett’s expecting cocktails or a full bar menu; it’s a BBQ-focused smokehouse, not a bar-and-grill. Bennett’s doesn’t open until 11 a.m., so it’s not a stop for an early breakfast — plan on lunch or dinner instead. And if your group has picky eaters or wants more than BBQ, Local Goat’s larger menu (burgers, salads, steaks) gives you more to work with than Bennett’s smoked-meat-focused lineup.
Explore more: More Pigeon Forge restaurant guides.
Bennett’s BBQ vs Local Goat FAQs
Which is cheaper, Bennett’s BBQ or Local Goat?
Bennett’s is generally the more budget-friendly option for smoked-meat platters, sandwiches, and burgers. Local Goat’s dinner menu (gourmet burgers, steaks, cocktails) runs a bit higher.
Do I need a reservation at Local Goat?
It’s not required but strongly recommended, especially for dinner or groups larger than eight. Reservations for ten or fewer can be made online; larger parties should call ahead.
Does Bennett’s BBQ have a full bar?
No, Bennett’s is a BBQ-focused restaurant without the cocktail and craft beer program that Local Goat offers.
What time does Bennett’s BBQ open in Pigeon Forge?
The Pigeon Forge location opens at 11 a.m. daily, so it’s a lunch-and-dinner stop rather than a breakfast spot.
Are Bennett’s and Local Goat both on the Parkway in Pigeon Forge?
Yes. Bennett’s is at 2910 Parkway (between traffic lights #4 and #5), and Local Goat is at 2167 Parkway near Rowdy Bear’s Smoky Mountain Snowpark.
Plan Your Smokies Trip
Build your own Smoky Mountains itinerary — save the cabins, attractions, and restaurants you want to hit. Try the free ExploreTheSmokies trip builder.
Photo by Leslie Cross on Unsplash.